Upon the recommendations of others here in response to my questions a coupla weeks ago, I took our group to Wonky Dog on Anegada and to Scaramouche in West End. Thoughts on each:

Wonky Dog: Loved it. The lobsters were delicious, and the the food as well as the presentation and service far superior to what we had experienced at the Reef Hotel the last couple of trips. Got to meet both Peter and Desne Penman, super nice folks. Two thumbs up.

Scaramouche: Totally enjoyable dining experience. Yes, it's expensive, but given the incredible menu and outstanding quality of the cuisine, we still considered it a good value. I had quite a group of foodies on this trip, including a serious chef, and they all enjoyed it so much the evening we arrived in West End, they insisted on reservations for our last night before departure! One note - as we left I said to one of the owners "See you next time!" to which he quietly replied "If we're still here." It would be a crying shame to let this place go away; if you're up for a memorable meal, give them a try!

Totally agree with both your reviews..had brunch at "Scaramouche" yesterday and they are preparing for their second anniversary..dont think they are going anywhere..just wish they could get enough staff to resume their amazing lunches!