ruralcarrier said:
Unless one flies from the East coast, you are pretty much going to pay very high fares. The (North) East coast seems to be the only place there is any real competition.
I think one needs to make choices. Our experience flying from Chicago to SXM is that the cheapest flights are when the bookings just open 11 months ahead of time. Rates from our area are in the $525 range for round trip flights in December 2017. JD, rates for that same time period from Dayon are $800.
