I was wondering where the answers would fall. We are May people and it seems like many others are too! I'm cheap and May rates are good and I'd prefer fewer crowds, May has that too. The only downside for us it that just happens to be when we have our best weather at home but that's ok with us because May works so well for us in the BVI.

Really you just never know. We've done May, June, July, September, October and December at least once. We did get a hurricane to the south in September and held up in in Cane Garden some wind and rain that cost us almost 2 days. In December we had some swell I was surprised how many of our favorite anchorages the swell kept us out of. Neither happens in May. I'll take any month of the year, no problems but we just like May because it usually has the right stuff for us.