Thank you both. Looking forward to hearing more RonDon when you have the time. No those are my only two options. We are fairly early eaters for dinner - say 6:00pm and would likely head back to condo after that. So not out late. Gosh we sound boring! The tripadvisor reviews are better for OBBC than Simpson but they are pretty close. Most agree the beach at OBBC is better...from pictures I can't really tell if Dawn beach is easy walking distance or not. I obviously need to do more research . My week choices are 12/16-12/23 or 12/9-12/16...airfare lower for the 12/16 week..don't know if it makes a difference on the island from one week to the next. Another question - water temp in December? Comfortable? upper 75's to 80's? Thank you again..feel like I am asking too much!!