I agree. We have same (2 br, 2 bath, sleep 6) right on the beach for $1,175/wk @ Belair. BUT, we have seen comparable offers via rental that enable you to go when you want (avoid the mob scene on Sat/Sun to go through Customs and Immigration). We, too have enjoyed our ts but that is subject to change dependent upon assessment and maintenance charges.
If we were to discontinue our ts, we may well go with rental @ Belair. It just opens other options.