Thanks. My wife and I recently went to Couples Resort San Souci in Jamaica. We sought a similar experience to Club O and overall were disappointed. We were angry at ourselves for not going to St Martin but got spooked by the Hurricane damage. We aren't going to repeat that mistake and will resume visiting St Martin 3-4 times/year and I've already booked 2 trips (just haven't secured a hotel yet).

I guess the question for people like me that are seeking a clothing optional experience (especially since staying at Club O isn't viable currently) is:

1- Does it make more sense just to rent a condo or other hotel and just walk down to the Club O beach and forget about staying at a clothing optional place for the time being; or
2- Does it make sense to stay at one of these other venues (I was unaware there were these 3). If so, which one?

I would think that many naturalists are asking the same question.