I have not stayed at either place, but I did attend a lobster dinner at Adam et Eve in June (when there were no guests). There is no ocean view, but I thought the property was lovely. We were given a tour of the whole facility. Rooms were spacious and appeared to be well equipped. I don't know if this is AI, but Willie, the general manager of the place, is an excellent chef and also makes his own ice cream. The property itself appeared quite lush, even in June.