Well, as the OP I'll be able to offer some thoughts and opinions after staying at Adam & Eve in February. I've booked us for eight nights and then we're off to Anguilla for another two nights. Got a nice little condo in Shoal Bay for a little under $500 per night after cleaning and airbnb fees (a bargain by Anguilla standards). Glad we saved some money by staying at Adam & Eve but I will miss those Orient Bay views at Club F. We are looking forward to staying at a new to us nudist place, though.