This board is mostly about sailing and sailing charters - most of the chat here is about that. Where people are fishing, they are generally doing it off the bat of their own, or chartered, sail boats or power cats. I don't know much about day charters for fishing, but a quick look at Trip Advisor shows up a few options... which come with customer feedback reviews. Have you checked out Trip Advisor? https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attract...Islands-Tortola_British_Virgin_Isla.html