My first choice of what was listed would be La Vista, love the feel of the resort, peaceful. My second choice would be RI LP, different reasons and places to go from there and walk to. From there to go to Taco Macho, the Maho Area or the Cupecoy area you are walking distance or a no traffic drive. You can also pick which way from there to go to and from Orient. My third choice would be as Elizabeth stated, Atrium which has a great location to walk to different Simpson Bay area places to drink and eat. We have stayed at Sea Palace and going in if you have the right attitude and are able to find parking it is not all bad. Older and no where near the others for condition of units but there are positives there as well. Probably one of the best front desk and housekeeping services that we have had on island, but again the property is worn. The positive is it would be easier to get to Orient. Divi is also a nice property, remote but an easy to and from Orient.
Have a great trip!