Oh ... another place I just remembered that many of the locals recommend is Sale & Pepe which is also in the general area (Welfare Road). But, it may be a bit on the expensive side for dinner and I know they don't serve breakfast here. In all honesty it's hard to visit St. Maarten and not have fantastic dining experiences. The number of good restaurants here on both sides is remarkable, and as you might be able to tell from this forum many people keep returning to SXM for the dining first, and the beaches second.

BTW, where is Stouffville, Ontario? Sounds like it's in the Vaughn area north of metro Toronto. I know Ontario very well from my travels but never heard of this town.