@WashKate, I'm sure bailau will chime in shortly. The majority of our island trips we stay on Anegada. As he stated, the snorkeling is the best from Flash of Beauty up to Big Bamboo. I feel like both Big Bamboo and Cow Wreck have good food. Our preference is Cow Wreck because of the party atmosphere that seems to happen regularly there. But honestly, either place for food is good.