The Buccaneer was great when we stayed there but it's been almost 20 years so I'm not sure how it is now. At the time we were there the rooms were tastefully appointed with beautiful tile and nice furnishings. The resort was well kept and the management was invested in pleasing the guests (my sister in law worked there at the time so it was not just an impression it was her experience - she was CFO and was part of said management.) She's not there anymore and I don't know what else has changed but I'd book there without hesitation as I'd be curious to see. Also, we had friends who stayed at Carambola for their honeymoon just last month and they loved it there if you want to consider that, it is a little more remote which they were looking for but you may not be. Whatever you decide enjoy and post a trip report when you get back!