Just my 2 cents. We chartered a Bali 4.3 a few years ago from DYC. Never again. It was brand new and had more problems than any other boat we have ever had (8 trips). We have chartered Lagoon 450 from them and they are great. And we like DYC but prefer TMM now.
We were down in June and October, 2019. In all the times we had been down, we had never tried Foxys Taboo. We were extremely disappointed. No one else around and we were snubbed. Finally asked someone to take our order, 6 drinks. Watered down and tasted weird. We did like B line for games and drinks. Skip it and eat at Hendo’s. Very good food and the staff actually smiles and seems so happy.
We love Scrub Island. And yes, it is way cheaper for the crew to extend the charter for 1 night instead of staying in the hotel.
Tip: the breakfast tacos in the market are really good, and affordable. The market is pretty expensive.
Have a blast!