We have been to St John and stayed in Villa Colorado. Was very nice and the owner is nice, friendly and very helpful. It is a 4 BR and all BR's have a King bed and their own bathroom/showers. You can take 1 BR or up to all 4. First time 3 were 3 couples and second time 2 couples.

We have been looking into Island Time, Limin Time and Terrahawk. They look interesting for 2 couples.