In MHO the best deal on St John is Dolphin Run on HArt Bay, two hills from Cruz bay as I say...far enough away though. I am staying there next month again. $1995 off season for 2-4 it is a 4 bedroom walk down to hart bay, two sliders in both master masters with views to die for. No air which is why I think it stays so reasonable. In 2005 we stayed in August and only one night were we hot, and only while we had to close the sliders due to rain. Just high enough for fab breezes. it is through caribbean villas.