I would do the 3 in Anegada and 2 in VG...

recommend getting a taxi instead of jeep in Anegada. Have Sherwin or Kelly take you out on the reef. We are in the Kelly camp

go see bar at the End of the World at Cow Wreck Beach, Flash of Beauty for snorkeling and then chicken roti there or go next store to Loblolly

Lunch at Hendos per Jason's recommendation. Dinner with Cynthia at Harris is great.

Coco Maya is a must...see Baths via taxi from Leverick in afternoon and dinner at CM right next door that night

Do you have Scotts cruising Guide to BVI?