Thanks for the input. Still exploring all options for Barcelona, Mallorca, and Florence. Using Joe Bananas for Amalfi. They get great reviews. Using Bobs for my 3 transfers. Using private car on arrival into Rome. Thinking of using the shuttle to port and from port to airport. Have you used the shuttle or only private car service with them? Wondering if private car to the ship would be better. On the return don't care shuttle is fine as we have all day. We don't fly out until the next morning. It is a lot more for the private car vs shuttle to the port and from what I am reading a lot of times you end up being the only one on it anyway.