Amen to that, LocalSailer! St. John, in particular, has several spectacular anchorages.

Sorry to hear about your negative experience, Bvicatter. We chartered with CYOA countless times for 35 years and were big fans. Though we chartered with 3 or 4 other outfits from time to time, no one else compared.
We chartered this winter with Waypoints (CYOA's successor) and were exceedingly pleased. We've already booked a boat for next year out of their St. Thomas base. Looking forward to seeing Jay and company.