I guess I can understand the late arrival, early departure rationale. But, I can not imagine four people fitting into one room. They are tiny.
The last time we stayedt there, the thermostat was broken and the room was a meat locker. The bed was lumpy and the bathroom was tiny and in need of an update.
I would still opt for a Hampton Inn and a five minute cab ride. Think hat CGB has a very good idea. We missed a flight recently because of traffic and had to stay in San Juan for a night. We were in a little after 5 PM and had a late morning flight to VG. So we stayed at the El San Juan and turned a very frustrating day into the begining of a great vacation.
At least we can disagree without being disagreeable. That isn't always the case here.