We are not renting a car this year for the first time in 30 years. We're staying at Maho and everything is right there. Parking is $5/day, so we probably won't even use a car that much if we do rent one and why pay to have it sit in a garage? I find I don't see as well at night to drive, so when we stayed at our timeshare; we limited driving to mostly Simpson Bay area anyway. I've gone back and forth on this one, but figure if we need a car; we can always rent one for a couple days once we get there, other than that we'll probably do cabs. This will definitely be a very unique experience for us this time around.