I see you are from Ontario, just curious why you use AA
WestJet flies Tues [and Thursday / Sunday] from Toronto non stop. I check each yr, I see the AA flight, but it’s normally about the same price as WJ, but with a stop. Never tried Delta, they often have the best price, but it changes in JFK with less than an hour between flights.
For us non stop is worth the price, plus Toronto has WJ – 3 flights wkly, AC - 2 flights, Sunwing - 2 flights and ATrans - 1 flight. However with the Can dollar going down, SXM is starting to get expensive, wonder if some of the flights wall disappear if demand drops.
J&B