Sticker shock is very real in the Bahamas. Cable beach is very nice, will actually be there in 2 weeks. The nicest market for grocery shopping is Solomons Fresh Market - Old Fort Bay. https://amlfoods.com/solomons-fresh-markets/locations.html
Based on your previous trips, might suggest Puerto Rico--lots of history, shopping, casinos, the rain forest. Also Antigua, again, lots of history, scenery, casinos. Enjoy!
Last I’d read, cruise lines were setting up lounges and other amenities in Spring Bay for passengers, similar to Lindqvist/Smith Bay - Is that correct? And is anything like that going on at Savannah?
Come to the British Virgin Islands..lots of varierty..stay on Tortola's North/West shore for snorkelling and taje day trips to other islands..so much choice.Pop ovdeer tto the BVI page and get more info..