Thanks for all the suggestions again and keep them coming! Still leaning towards Tortola for reasons stated but we are keeping an open mind.

Thoughts on Cane Garden Bay? Worried that the busy beach would get tiresome after a few days. But there is a couple of nice villas on the west side of the bay that have potential.

Anyone know the link to the cruise ship schedule for 2017? I also need to check for my sail planning as well.