Bamaboy

Personally - Love the beaches in St John, Coral Bay, Skinny Legs, Beach Bar - great Island. It is a solid time.

I do not have experience with St Croix - never been. IMHO - if you could get to St Croix (not sure if your charter company would allow it) - I would say go for it! It is on my list for sure.

I have a boat sitting in Tortola - I can definitely see having is ran over to Red Hook and I take it around St John and down to St Croix. Looking forward to that actually. And, that works on a 7 day trip - which is 95% of all charter durations.