Emilio's
Moulin Fou
Mario's

Probably fit what you are looking for and for me in nearly that order although I might put Moulin Fou on the top.

Sublime was acceptable but I would not at all put as fine dining.
A lot of people like Jax, doesn't grab me.
As for Palapa, might try it sometime but usually gravity takes me across the street to The Palms.

Cheers,
T

I pimp DK Gems, The Palms, Lal's, La Chingona, Dany's at Cupecoy and Friars Bay Beach Club !