You guys are all so helpful! I shared some of the feedback with my husband and he now agrees we should spend the night on St. Thomas. I've since gone down the VRBO and Air B&B rabbit hole, lol. Mostly looking at Sapphire Village, but what's the scoop on Point Pleasant? Haven't seen it discussed much but this condo looks pretty nice, especially for the price. Is there any reason to avoid this complex?
Point Pleasant condo

Oh, and Skipdastraw, thanks for that link. Definitely looking at some of that host's properties. That 12:00 check out is really appealing!