Thanks Fitz & betsyg. Trying the codeshare route to VIJ (CLT-SJU-VIJ) doesn't get me into VIJ before 5:30pm and is $1800 RT main cabin. If I go CLT-MIA-EIS it is $1000 RT main cabin and I get in around 2pm. That route still gives me an opportunity to get to Anegada the same day.

The codeshare to VIJ route had me on Cape Air from SJU. Not Tradewinds. The dates maybe? I am looking at 11/18-28/2024. I can be flexible with the dates.

I also looked at not codesharing. CLT-SJU-VIJ. CLT-SJU (AA) is around $500 RT main cabin but Tradewinds doesn't show any flights in November yet. So I'll check that over the next few months as they apparently don't book that far out.