Great report. You've given us some thought to renting as you did in Grand Case.

We too own at Divi and in the past (before JetBlue direct flights) we would leave mid-week stay 3 days at Grand Case Beach Club before heading to Divi where we are in a duplex facing Great bay. Hubby used to say he wished we could put that unit on Grand Case and not have to rent a car since we seem to eat there most of the time.
These days we alternate years between a week at GCBC & two at Divi.

Where did you stay?