Sounds like your first trip to St John? Do you know if you want to be close to Cruz Bay or is a 30 minute drive to Coral Bay ok? Once we have a location, for us it's usually Bourdeaux Mountain/Coral Bay side, Here's how we begin our searches..........
My wife and I search the local villa websites, especially those with availability calendars. For the heck of it, I just did a quick search on
www.Vivacations.com for random 2 weeks in Jan 2014. I saw Mayan Sky was available for $4400wk. We've stayed at this villa, maybe 5 years ago, it's in Upper Carolina and has beautiful mountain/valley views and of the harbor in Coral Bay. The location is 25 minutes to Cruz Bay, less than 10 minutes to Maho Bay and same for Coral Bay restaurants/groceries.
After we find a couple villas that look good to us we immediately contact our friend Denise at
www.onlinevacations.com and let her take over from there. Denise has been on St John over 30 years and her local knowledge is priceless. She manages a couple nice properties in Cruz Bay, but she can assist with any villa and her services don't cost you a thing.
I like doing the villa searches even when it's not for me! PM your dates, budget, must haves etc and I'll search away. <img src="http://www.traveltalkonline.com/forums/images/graemlins/Cheers.gif" alt="" />