Returning to the VIs in 10 days (alas no BVIs this trip) & doing a sleep aboard the 1st night in Redhook. We need to find a place for dinner on the 1st night before we start our cruise and would welcome suggestions. We have 8 couples (2 boa\ts of 4 couples each) and probably would lean towards nicer (good food wise rather than dress up wise) and would appreciate any recommendations. The crew of our boat suggested Mims, but it has some dodgy recent reviews (I know what reviews can be like so I take them all with SEVERAL grains of sal\t). Any ideas?