For me it's a bit of a toss-up, and I've done it each way maybe 10 or so times round-trip over the years. It's either a direct flight to STT or a hop through SJU for us coming out of Newark NJ; a lot of times it depends on the timing of available flights. More and more, I'm not a fan of the logistics at SJU and it's nice to have just one flight. I think the best way I've done it thus far, which has only been once, is going through STT and using a reserved water taxi to Road Town. We had a party of 10 traveling together, and this really worked nicely.