Just fyi - for future reference, check out Caribbean Cellars too, we've used them many times and always had success. TICOs and CC are significantly less expensive provisioning options.

Loading booze onto the boat is an added bonus....we've spent a little time waiting on charter company folks locating our orders. (pro tip: if you end up with an extra case or two, bottle, etc., I recommend setting that aside knowing someone will be back in the morning for it...)

PS - What did you decide about car rental VG? Curious...