Storm,
I have a crew of 8, so I would need something along the lines of a Cessna Caravan. That would likely run as more or more than Cape Air.
I love the BVI because despite the crowds, the sailing is so damn easy.
But I'm considering seeing if Sunsail will let me transfer my reservation to say St. Marten where I can fly direct.
I guess I got spoiled when AA was flying into Beef.
.
