We ate dinner there on Wednesday night and had an excellent experience. The views are absolutely fantastic and the food was very good. Service was far better than any other place we have ever been to in the BVI. The ambiance is more consistent with a restaurant in a place like St. Barth which is one of our favorite islands so maybe that is one of the reasons we enjoyed it so much. Entree prices are consistent with other higher end restaurants in the BVI so I would not characterize it as over priced. Our bills from Brandywine, Corsairs, and Peter Island on this trip were within plus or minus 10% of YCCS. We have not made it to Norman island on this trip but I expect Pirate's to be comparable if not higher in price.