Highly recommend CYOA! Chartered with them for the first time March '18 and again this past March. Wondering why it took us so long to figure out that being on the boat 10 minutes after walking out of STT is a no brainer. No more ferry headache! Last year we charted a 45' Beneteau, this year a Lagoon Cat. Both boats were in excellent condition and everything worked as expected including the water makers. We used the chart plotter and auto pilot the entire time. Give CYOA a call, I'm sure you'll have a very positive experience through every step of the process.
Another “Pro” for CYOA is you arrive in Old French Town where you have a variety of excellent restaurants with good service and a non stressed out marina and without the crowds that you would find in Manhattan at rush hour >>>Roadtown Tortola.
BTW CYOA is located where the first charter boat company in the Virgin Islands was opened ( Avery’s Boathouse)