We are regulars (multiple times a year) at Club O but have visited Hidden Beach a couple of times. Last time was in 2007 so our views may be a bit dated. The rooms are good (on the first floor they have direct access to the rather extended pool. The staff is really outstanding: friendly and eager to help. They make you feel at home. The bar is good, and it takes some self control to avoid drinking way too much. (I realize that most of us want to drink a bit too much). The pool is nice, but the long arms are too narrow and too shallow to get much of a workout. The food is actually quite good, and the dress code is totally absent (that is, in my opinion, good). The negative and the reason we keep coming back to Club O is that there is no meaningful access to the sea. That is, the beach is really well hidden, so you can't really swim in the ocean. But for that fact we would be more frequent customers at HB.