I agree about the Anguilla day I wouldnt want to lose any of my precious 3 days if i was you. If you do go to the lolo's then you could make a day of it on the beach in Grand Case. Stroll the streets and read the menus, more than likely you will get hungry again and make dinner reservations to go back to that night.

As for Divi, i have heard but not had the luxury of trying that the restaurant at Divi is much much better. They apparently have a new executive chef and he is revamping the whole thing. Sometimes the best choice for the first night is eating at the resort so thought i would throw that out there.