Thank you all for replying! It sounds like Anegada is worth it. We have the boat for 10 nights, so we should be able to fit it in. How far in advance should I rent the car if we plan to arrive mid-morning? Can you get them that day in case we alter our itenerary and go on a different day? I have also read that it is fun to rent a car for the day on VG. Any thoughts on this are also appreciated!

Last edited by steve74; 04/14/2016 08:24 PM.