Has anyone stayed at scrub island and if so what was your experience?

On a boat or in a room?

We've stay on a boat and had a great time. We've had friends that have stayed in the rooms and had a great time as well.

Now that we have a 16 month old, staying there for us was awesome. The pool was great and we even enjoyed the north beach a bit.

We stayed at Scrub this past April for 2 nights pre-charter. The rooms & grounds are beautiful. Check in staff were wonderful. The pools are nice (lots of kids though). Food was average and they were out of quite a few things on the menu. They have a decent provisioning shop which serves great breakfast sandwiches. Wait staff seemed very indifferent.
All in all .... if we were paying full price for the room (we used Marriott points) I wouldn't do it again.
(This was just my husband and I - no kids with us)

I wonder how many people actually pay for rooms?

Two people I know that have stayed both used Marriott points too.

We last stayed in May and the whole place was very quiet. Not many kids at all either - only ones we saw were college age.

Stayed in the marina and liked it.