We always go to both on every charter.

We love the view from the infinity pool at Scrub and having dinner and drinks at the inside bar while watching the sunset down the Sir Francis Drake Channel. We also find the staff pleasant and a few of them usually remember us from previous visits which is nice. For us personally, it is a nice mid-charter break from the sand, wind and salt. As stated though, if you don't like typical American resorts you probably won't love the atmosphere are Scrub. It is a bit more laid back than your typical resort IMO - just not your typical Caribbean vibe.

Leverick is great for many reasons as well. From the friendly and familiar staff to the accessibility it offers to Virgin Gorda, not to mention generally more reasonable pricing than Scrub. Their pool is just as refreshing (though it doesn't have the view or slide), the food in the upstairs restaurant at Leverick is every bit as good as Cavalara at Scrub, the downstairs restaurant very good as well with much affordable fare, a good store for provisioning, laundry machines if you run out of clean clothes, etc... The one thing it "lacks" is an overly resorty atmosphere.