Leverick would be my choice as an always stop.
Scrub pool/poolbar is nice. Restaurant was good. Dock check in was poor and did not honor the advertised rate even when I showed them the ad. Eventually got credit after several emails (the principle of not honoring the advertised TTOL discount irritated me, especially when I found out it had happened to many.)

Nick, on the other hand, has always gone above and beyond... Once no one came for mooring ball fee and we had to leave early(before dock opened, emailed Nick asking for address and he graciously said the night was "on the house"... The principle behind his being so gracious gets me back to Leverick every trip for at least 1 night, and frequently 2 nights.