I can't do a one versus the other, there's an obvious difference between them and we have always had a great time at both. We do appreciate how welcome Nick and Monica make us feel when we are there, that is a special draw for us. We travel in the summer months when the crowds are low, our experiences at both have been relaxing with great service. As far as Scrubs atmosphere, if you want the cool travertine tile feel, sure it's there, but they also offer an out of the way quiet place too. We have hiked to it a few times and we have been driven there by the free shuttle and they will return to pick you up when you want. Try wandering around you might be surprised at what's just around the corner!