I agree with the posters above.
I am an experienced diver, and have done this trip 8 times (at least), so here's my 2 cents:
Rum: we just stick with Meyers for mixing
Spa: you won't need it because you are so happy and relaxed. Book a spa for the Monday after you get home.
Fishing: not worth the hassle.
Scuba: not the best diving, but the Rhone is worth it if you have never been. But only in good visibility. I normally skip it now.
SUP: Yes worth it. Also, it makes a nice bar on the beach, as well as an escape hatch when your crew starts to annoy you.
Food: I like Willy T for a group dinner too. Easy...and entertainment is free. Sometimes its easier to break up for dinner. The big group can slow you down.
Enjoy, you are going to love it.
Not to derail the thread, but interested in your dive recommendation for places much better than BVI. We are long time skin divers, but newer to scuba and have only Mexico, Hawaii, San Juan's and Thailand to compare and have not found better diving than in the BVI.
