We visited Pinel Island once and that was enough for us. We visited Anse Marcel once and haven't felt a need to return. When Orient Beach (Club O end) is too much for us we walk to Le Galion. It is a wonderful calm beach with one restaurant. (And I discovered they sell sunscreen cheaper than the French side grocery stores!). Anyway we have not been to Baie Rouge but may have to pay it a visit next year.