We did our first BBC with Moorings and it was selected because of all the guarantees about boat qualities and on-the-water service. Since then, we have used Sunsail and have been equally satisfied. The reviews for BVIYC sound intriguing. The option of having an ice maker in the post above is killer! If it were me, with just two aboard, I would opt for a monohull of at least 38 ft. In my opinion, they offer better sailing characteristics than a small cat, but then, you can't beat the spaciousness of a cat. Have fun selecting your ride and have a fun, safe trip.