A shameless plug for CYOA...

First a disclaimer - I'm not professionally affiliated with CYOA and do not own a boat in charter with them. However, we have chartered from them for 31 years, so I might be a little biased... they are like family to me.

The two Mahe 36 cats from CYOA are perfect for two couples and are little speed demons.

Flying into St. Thomas is often cheaper and faster than flying into the BVI.

Flying into St. Thomas saves you time and aggravation of a ferry ride to the BVI.

CYOA has a great price-point on their boats, and you'll find that while most of their boats have Gen/AC and other expensive amenities that Moorings/Sunsail do not (as a rule).

CYOA has awesome staff willing to go the extra mile for you!