Not too far from Shoal Bay East in Island Harbor is Elite (Italian) and Falcons Nest - fish/lobster, plus Artisan Pizza, hand made Napolean pizza in an oven that was imported from Italy, along with other home made Italian food, they all get great reviews. On Da Rocks is in Island Harbor and they had $5.00 crayfish and $5.00 sides on Sat and Sundays, but they are closed now and have not heard if they are reopening.
Ellen