In the East End, Hibernia is a lovely option for a special dinner. I know it's not to everyone's taste, but the fish they serve is sublime, and there's an Asian/Fusion flair to the food. Excellent wine list also.

The Malliouhana restaurant is also wonderful!! Given the high prices in general on Anguilla, it's not that outrageous and I would choose to eat a couple of meals in and forego the moderate, mediocre fare at some of the more casual restaurants and splurge on dinner there. Lunch is also fantastic, and it's such a lovely setting. You can spend a morning on the beach at the base of the hotel and then have lunch.

Finally, the Best Buy supermarket on the way toward the East End and Shoal Bay, and Proctor's right in The Valley, offer delicious rotisserie chicken that you can pick up for a simple lunch or dinner at the villa, if you don't feel like cooking and don't feel like eating out. The quality of the veggies available for fresh salads is also fantastic. Roast chicken, a lovely green salad, and a bottle of Rose from Tropical Distributors (also near Best Buy), and you're good to go :~).