Personally I think I would grab a mooring ball of Honeymoon in STJ. Send the CAPT (that would be you) to meet the guest. Maybe stop at Tutu Mall and do a stock up on some more libations and call it a vacation.

Doing this will allow the CAPT to be relieved (for a minimum of 24 hours) of any dishes, clean up, or trash removal.

And if you have to wait for a late flight... the hotel across the parking lot has a nice bar on the water and you can see when the plane lands. Make it easy for everybody.